Posted by
DL Cummings on Thursday, June 28, 2007 2:21:44 PM
A recent Gallup poll
[1][2] suggests that Americans trust the military and the police force more than they do the church and organized religion.
I'm sure you are quite aware of how polls are conducted and by shifting the wording of the question one can shift the answer received. In this case it appears the question left a considerable amount open to the respondent.
"Now I am going to read you a list of institutions in American society. Please tell me how much confidence you, yourself, have in each one -- a great deal, quite a lot, some, or very little? "My issue here is what the people are basing their confidence on.
Is it the latest buzz in the news (say, Tim Haggard)?
Is it a single bad experience with a church they were just at?
Did someone they know have a bad experience?
Additionally, one must consider the role that each respondent feels the church has in society (which I think more to the point). Thus, asking the average gay person might draw a different response than asking the typical heterosexual person.
The responses do represent a problem, although more than just a trust issue. Obviously, the church/organized religion (euphemisms for the Catholic Church and Evangelical Churches) has done a poor job of not only building trust in the populace, but also maintaining a static purpose in society.
Going further with this, it is reasonable to suggest the church has failed on an academic level as well (possibly more importantly).
Initially the church promulgated the concept of public schools to educate the masses (notably for scripture reading). However, since the inculcation of the public school system into the government they have went not only private, but generally expensively so. This leaves academia up for grabs and allows for a re-education of the masses on a social level (apart from say standard mathematics and reading) by another entity. Thus, the purpose of the church in society changes in the minds of people when it shouldn't.
Looking at a few of the institutions (those with the most recorded responses) the percentage change from its highest year and lowest year we can sort the group on an increasing scale. This allows us to show specifically which institutions had the greatest degree of change.
Maximum change from the highest year to the lowest year
|
Military |
35 percentage points |
|
Banks |
30 percentage points |
|
Newspapers |
29 percentage points |
|
Congress |
28 percentage points |
|
Schools |
25 percentage points |
|
Church |
23 percentage points |
|
TV News |
23 percentage points |
|
Supreme Court |
22 percentage points |
|
Organized Labor |
20 percentage points |
|
Big Business |
16 percentage points |
The military has the largest gap followed (in order) by banks, newspapers, congress and schools. The church/organized religion rates number six along with TV News. On a good note, the church isn’t in the top five of fluctuation, which means it has managed to keep a fairly reasonable profile of itself.
It does look like there is a downward trend. We can see that over the years the church has a low point and then a few good years, although the trend still is going down overall. The church has quite a bit of work ahead, not only spiritually, but also academically and socially. One must wonder if the church is up to the task; I’m thinking not—though surprises abound.